The Hermitage Artist Retreat has asked Sarasota County commissioners for permission to assume ownership of its historic campus on Manasota Key, a move leaders say would save taxpayer dollars and speed up storm recovery.
The nonprofit currently leases the properties at 6630–6660 Manasota Key Road from the county. In a statement, Hermitage officials said the landlord-tenant relationship has become increasingly difficult, especially following natural disasters such as Hurricanes Helene and Milton.
Hermitage staff said they acted quickly to repair storm damage last year, removing sand and mitigating water damage at their own expense. Contractors had prepared to fully restore the site within 45 to 60 days. But the county directed the organization to stop, taking over recovery efforts. Nearly a year later, officials said, half of the campus buildings remain untouched.
“We are as baffled as you by these delays,” the statement read, adding that vulnerable buildings are now entering another hurricane season unrepaired.
Despite setbacks, Hermitage leaders credit donors and staff for replanting the campus, restoring dunes and reopening the Hermitage House. They said county contractors have not been on-site for months and have not provided a timeline for repairs.
By assuming ownership, the Hermitage said, it could ensure quicker responses in the future while relieving the county of property management duties. Beach access would remain unchanged, and the group pledged to continue offering free and low-cost cultural programs to the community.
“This will have only positive impact on the public,” the Hermitage board wrote, calling the proposal a “win-win” for all parties.
The County Commission is expected to vote on the ownership request this week. Hermitage officials expressed hope that commissioners would support the transfer, noting they still have nearly 30 years left on their current lease.
“The reality is that the County staff simply does not have the bandwidth to properly manage the Hermitage properties,” the statement said. “Caring for the campus remains a top priority for our board, staff and supporters.”
